In Chapter 12 – Individual Selection as a Social Process, Sampson writes,
“Individuals “escape” poverty, for example, by differentially allocating
themselves non-randomly according to their ability and preferences”; in other
words, choice matters.
Why do people chose to move to different
neighborhoods? Members of minority or immigrant groups attempt to translate
economic advances into residential advantage by moving out of segregated areas
and into areas occupied by members of the dominant race/ethnic group. According
to Sampson, movers gain more by contrast, particularly those exiting to the
suburbs, but in a way that just shifts the race gaps in parallel fashion. For
example, in Sampson’s survey, the total annual income change for white movers
who exited the city was a substantial $18,400. The total gain in neighborhood
median income for black movers who exited Chicago was $13,900, and for Latinos
and Hispanics, the gain was about $17,300. Bottom-line, all groups experienced
a positive slope of change.
According to Sampson blacks live in
neighborhoods that are composed almost exclusively of members of their own
race; whites live in neighborhoods with lower proportions of blacks than
Latinos/Hispanics no matter where they move. How likely is it that their individual choices will transform
the communities they will leave or enter? Neighborhood residential mobility entails
a break with the social relationship and networks developed in one’s origin
neighborhood and the forced development or isolation from new social ties in
another place; which may be “good” or “bad”. For example, a move may mean a
loss of social capital available to children through the disruption of
intergenerational networks and collective efficacy available to children. But
disruption can also mean breaking away from disadvantaged and violent
environment, providing benefits if the new neighborhood is supportive and safe.
If “bad” people move, neighborhoods may improve. If “good” people move,
neighborhoods lose human potential; thus, those who stay may become even more
“attached” to the poverty trap.
Yes, choice does matter, but poverty traps
are difficult to escape, especially for those with cognitive vulnerabilities,
little confidence and lack of social support systems. With my emphasis in
business and recreation management, I will bring the “neighborhood” to the
people. Rather than neighborhoods lose their most precious resources such as
human potential to some other neighborhood, I plan to bring structure and
opportunity to them. I will create a network that will cater to those with
vulnerabilities such as depression, family criminality, and exposure to
violence, and lack of education and social support. No matter if white, black, Hispanic/Latino,
Asian Pacific American, or a member of any other racial group, I will induct
them into an environment created for success. I will provide an infrastructure
of public safety, healthcare, education, resources and teach them to maintain
it on their own.
Great Post, it helped me understand Sampsons points a little more. I especially enjoyed the prescriptive that since races tend to live together the community is less likely to feel the loss when they move...that is so interesting. I also liked the concept of good and bad disruption, something I had never thought about before.
ReplyDelete